Friday, October 4, 2013
Open To Interpretation
In 12S, we have spent the past couple of classes discussing pastoral poetry, which, surprisingly, I enjoyed. They were so cute! All about the ups and downs of being caught up in a passionate relationship, from the happiness of being newly committed, as in The Voice of the Swallow, Flittering, Calls to Me, to the possible theme of heartbreak and betrayal in I Think I’ll Go Home and Lie Very Still. Despite references to a lifestyle much different from the present day, the poetry carried within it themes that are still very human and relatable, even after all these years. It is interesting to realize that even people, who lived thousands of years ago, in a time much different from my own, still felt and acted in ways much similar to myself and people that I know in the present day. But besides being cute and relatable, the thing I most enjoyed about reading the poetry was hearing the different interpretations that we all had. For example, the poem I Think I’ll Go Home and Lie Very Still, I interpreted to be about a person who was heartbroken, staying in bed out of sheer bitter and depressed disappointment, and his love gloating knowingly over his heartache. Kimoy, on the other hand, felt that the man was feigning illness in order to be able to see his beloved, who smiled knowingly because she knew the real reason behind his false illness was to see her, and she appreciated the gesture. Two very different interpretations, the same exact text, and both had textual support! I thoroughly enjoyed being able to think about a reading from multiple perspectives. Also, Mrs. Whitley’s genuine encouragement to make our own interpretations, even if they were contrary to each other’s and even her own, as long as we had support, made the class a lot more engaging and enjoyable.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I totally agree with you!!
ReplyDeletePastoral poetry is very interesting to discuss in class because there are many possibilities concerning what the author could have meant. It can get frustrating, especially when you think you completely understand the poem and then, someone gives their opinion and it changes your entire perspective.
ReplyDeleteIn all my years of learning literature, which obviously isn't a lot, I have never felt comfortable in expressing my opinion on what my class read. I always thought there was only one CORRECT way to interpret readings, poems, etc. Thankfully, Ms. Whitley has allowed us to express whatever we think with valid support, and I believe if all teachers were to give their students that advantage then many people would love literature. So basically, the main reason why people don't enjoy literature is because of that one teacher who frequently says, "No! Billy Bob, you're wrong!" Clearly, Billy Bob is never going to raise his hand again and now he will forever hate literature. All in all, I believe that being able to interpret literature however you want with valid support is important in order to become more knowledgable.
ReplyDeleteI hear what you're saying, and I'm thrilled to encourage you all to develop your interpretations of the text (as long as there's textual evidence of course). However, you have to remember, when you were younger, you may have needed more guidance. With my younger classes, I certainly do more guiding (and sometimes pushing) in an interpretive direction to help them develop the skill. So, instead of focusing on the past, I'd like you all to celebrate the fact that you're cognitively ready to not need that push anymore.
DeleteI enjoyed to pastoral poems..even though they were short, I could already imagine a whole story line (like Lorena) ... Then again I have a very vivid imagination... They made me want to be in love for a second.. Then I came back to reality!
ReplyDeleteI agree it is very interesting to see both sides of the same poem. While I saw it as the person feigning illness to see his beloved, I never thought to look at it through a different perspective.
ReplyDeleteSorry for being so late, lol. I really appreciated your viewpoint of the heart broken guy because personally I didn't think of it that way when I read and I like the fact that you acknowledged the different viewpoint that Kemoy had. Being able to see two sides of every story is a very admirable quality. Go ahead girl (:
ReplyDelete